The Fifteen Signs: Podcasting is a Rotting Husk
I love podcasts. Have done ever since I used to download episodes of The Australian Gamer to my Creative Zen Touch, and over the years I have hosted or guested on a number of podcasts, mainly in the video games space.
I'm saying this to give context, but also as an attempt to offer up my credentials - I know I'm not exactly the first person to be into podcasts, but I've had opinions on them and how they work for getting on for twenty years now, and in my job as a technical SEO I also have opinions on the delivery and distribution of content.
I've been around and I sort of know what I'm talking about, right?
So here's the big point I want to make: Podcasting, as it exists today, is a horrific misuse of the technology that powers them, bending XML to its absolute limit to push DRM and paygates into a service that actively wants information to be free and distributable. It's been leapt on and torn apart by capitalism's wild dogs in yet another act of bloodlust, and as someone who watched it happen in aching slow motion, it's just another example of the tech industry seemingly being hell bent on destroying and disgracing technology in the name of a shortsighted cashgrab.
But let's wind back to 2007 - Actually no, let's go back a bit further first.
1: The earth's waters rise above the mountains
If you're unaware, podcasts are powered by RSS. Yes, still. RSS feeds, the things old men like me used to put into Google reader in our attempt to curate the web to our own design and become our very own algorithm. James Acaster owes being a genie in the Albert Hall to RSS, Joe Rogan is a Kabillionaire because of RSS, and you've been getting My Dad Wrote a Porno recommended to you by normies for years because of RSS.
RSS is amazing, and in the early 2000s the standard was updated to allow files to be referenced within the markup, which then lead to the advent of Podcatchers; programs (or apps if you're young) that could parse RSS, download the files, and in some cases, even play them or transfer them to your enormous brick of an MP3 player. The fact that podcasts were powered by RSS was awesome, because it meant that wherever you had access to something that could understand an RSS feed, you had access to your favourite audio content - and because files could be fairly significantly compressed, the relatively low financial barrier to entry meant that anyone with a voice, an opinion and a laptop could get involved - true democratic content sharing, as per the ethos of the 90s/00s internet.
4: All sea animals gather on the surface and bellow unintelligibly
Then came 2007, and thus Apple, and while I don't love giving them their flowers in this story, their role in the growth of podcasting is inescapable. Getting your podcast on iTunes was a weird process, but not a difficult one - there were no listenership requirements, no complex exclusivity deals and no outside influence on the content; and what it suddenly meant was that everyone with an Apple device had equal access to just about every podcast on the web, all easily accessible in one place.
Remember that, it'll be important in a bit.
It really can't be overstated what having a trusted name like Apple providing a repo for podcasts did; this was a huge name in the tech space suddenly making spoken word content from all over the world and about just about anything suddenly incredibly accessible, and without this I do think that by now RSS feeds would be almost totally resigned to history, pushed out the door by an infinite army of square and curly brackets.
However; know what else Apple did? If your answer is "try to ruin it somehow", you're totally right and I see you've lived on this earth before. Apple started C&Ding podcatcher developers pretty aggressively, and while I don't think they ever did try to copyright the word, I do think they still believe they could if they want to - just another incredible piece of altruism from our fruity overlords.
6: Plants and trees fill with dew and blood
But how did we get here from there?
In my mind, there's been three big elbow points in the growth of podcasts: Most people, whether they remember it or not, first heard the word "podcast" on the end of the words "Ricky Gervais" in 2006-07, but it was the launch of Serial in 2014 that really revved the engine - Serial launched in late 2014, was an absolute smash hit, and then suddenly 2015 saw a 43% increase in the YoY growth of new podcast series on iTunes..
Serial was groundbreaking in a lot of ways because it was one of the first podcasts to be released in a limited, documentary style format - up until now most podcasts took a more panel or interview-led format, with no particular end goal in sight, usually put together by friends who would gather around a phone or in a Skype call to record their thoughts on the newest WWE hirings, or aliens or whatever.
But Serial was journalism, available for free in exchange for listening to that one guy saying "Mail...kimp?". It had plotting, and pacing, and was clearly a) a huge labour of love and b) a huge risk on the part of whoever commissioned it; a risk that really paid off. All of a sudden podcasts were a legitimate journalistic outlet, things that could actually generate revenue and attract new readers/listeners, as opposed to just a short lived project that two nerds in marketing pitched really hard for one year that got cut as soon as budgets got a little bit snug.
And still! Serial sat in my podcast app (I dunno when we stopped saying podcatcher) alongside Run Last Click (a podcast about Android: Netrunner, a card game that was seemingly cancelled by the publisher in a fit of pique), and a man called Stuart Goldsmith interviewing Standup comedians on the Comedian's Comedian podcast. Yes, Serial had a marketing budget behind it, but I could still go to iTunes, type in a phrase I was interested in and browse big shows by publishing organisations alongside hidden gems made by people with 20 Twitter followers.
9: The stones fight each other
Looking back, the next five years should have been more of an eye-opener than they were.
2014 saw the creation of Acast, offering Ad Tech to podcasters for the first time in the shape of dynamic ad inclusion, injecting ads into the file as it was downloaded by the user... to varying degrees of success (It often felt like if you got the episodes early enough, the ads wouldn't get injected, and I remember being amazed by the swing-and-a-miss of an Acast podcast advertising to me that a very specific Tesco was open after a refurb... in Cardiff, three hours away from where I live)
But still, this was it now. Ads weren't just limited to recordings at the start of the show or live reads in the middle, there was now tech involved. Sure, it pushed the first few fingertips into the cracks of podcasting's free and democratic nature, and I remember at the time not loving that an ad network now had a semi-autonomous voice within the space, but if it meant that people could get paid for their shows, I could stand it (I should add at this point that podcasting has only ever cost me money, with the exception of a run of tshirts I was involved in that made me a grand total of about 200 quid, money that definitely doesn't make up for the petrol and accommodation costs of live shows and the like we did).
Of course, at roughly the same time Patreon was offering another monetisation opportunity to podcasters; giving content creators a platform to manage the distribution of bonus content to paying patrons. Often, this did (and still does) include bonus podcasts, accessible via a special unique link that (I think) only works for as long as your subscription to that creator continues to exist.
And this is where I reach my next impasse. I really strongly believe that to be defined as a podcast, the media must be freely available to anyone with a tool that can make a GET request and parse an RSS feed - but obviously I also believe that human beings should be compensated for their labour.
I also don't like ads.
This is further compounded by the fact that, as mentioned, I have never even attempted to monetise any podcasting I have been involved in, partially due to the mechanisms not existing at the time, but also because of my aforementioned belief that nothing that calls itself a podcast should be put behind a paywall - However, Patreon does at least mean the content continues to be creator owned, the paid for stuff is an extra, the payment is optional and while Patreon obviously takes their cut, by paying into a feed you are more directly supporting a small business. Patreon, to me at least, is the version of Podcast monetisation that smells the least, to my tired old nose at least.
Anyway, 2015-2020 saw podcasts continue to grow at a decent pace as more and more audiences and publishers opened up to the idea (and realised it could be profitable), buoyed by some phenomenal pieces of journalism coming to mp3 before anywhere else (Check out Hunting Warhead or the Darknet Diaries episodes about Xbox hacking for just two examples)
Then, came the Pandemic.
12: Men come out from their hiding places but can no longer understand each other
I'm going to use The Computer Game Show as my frame of reference here (full disclosure, I am loosely affiliated with them, having appeared on a few youtube streams, and I am good friends with one of the hosts). They know what they're doing, and while they have a quite successful Patreon, the show is very much a side hustle, a side hustle that has only been making them money for a relatively small portion of their combined podcasting careers.
They record remotely over Zoom, and through forty or so years of combined experience, they're now at a point where unless you are an audio nut, you might not know.
So it came as a huge surprise to me (and them, I believe) when three months into the pandemic, the iTunes charts were suddenly awash with podcasts by household name comedians, complete with super professional cover art and the like... but they sounded like shit.
These were shows that would have the name of a production company attached to them; releasing badly put together content that was clearly being done in a hurry in order to generate some kind of revenue stream, and they were absolutely dominating the charts. For a long time this was a content format that had been ignored by most public figures, but now it was the only viable way of generating an income during the Lockdowns, they were all over it. Look at most podcast charts now and you will find that they are dominated by folk who were able to bring an enormous audience directly to their podcast, rather than growing the show organically - and with these huge audiences came the advertisers smelling chum in the water. All of a sudden podcasts would have two minutes of ads at the start, in the middle and at the end, and as if the advertisers didn't already have content creators over a barrel, the ads weren't live reads or pre-supplied pieces of content; they were instead ads created by the content creators themselves - dancing for their pennies from the ad networks.
So all this sucks, right? We have a medium that's been long overlooked by celebrity suddenly crushed under the weight of literally hundreds of thousands of new shows, many doing very well on the back of their famous hosts despite production values that would make many hobbyists shudder, full to the brim with ads done in an ironic having-my-cake-and-eating-it timbre by the hosts - but at least this is all still available in one app to anyone who has a podcatcher eh?
Enter: Fucking Spotify.
14: The bones of the dead come out of their graves
For years I'd sort of wished Spotify had some kind of podcast functionality - I use Spotify daily for music, and having two apps on my phone doing broadly the same thing for two very closely related forms of media (After all, a song is just a podcast with a guitar) seemed silly.
Well I'm pleased to announce the cursed monkeys paw curled shut on that little dream in 2020 when Spotify finally did move into the podcast space... and created a walled garden for the stuff they owned, at exactly the same time as Amazon decided Audible had podcasts on it too, and did the same with things like Alan Partridge: From the Oasthouse.
All of a sudden, not only were there entire podcast feeds now trapped behind a paygate, the content was now scattered between multiple apps on your phone, each asking for your money, your attention, and more importantly, getting in the way of just listening to the fucking audio, treating what used to be a democratically and freely distributed medium like the latest multi-million dollar premium TV series. I'd probably feel a little bit better about that if Joe fucking Rogan wasn't involved.
But what ultimately lead me to finally writing this post was a cross-network ad for a podcast. One of those ones where a podcast owned by the same company as one you like hijacks your feed for 4 minutes to shill themselves. Anyway, I read the blurb and thought "sure, sounds good!"
The only link in the blurb, though, was to a page that I couldn't access because I wasn't in the US - An advert for a product that I couldn't use. You've taken Really Simple Syndication and put DRM on it, put Geo Restrictions on it, put it behind a paywall, injected ads into it; you took a perfectly good distribution method and you gave it capitalism.
And the apps! The other week in the name of getting away from a UI change to Pod Republic that I hate, I tried a few other apps. Every single one is now riddled with transactions, with adverts for Joe Rogan, Featured segments and more - iPodderX will be rolling in its grave.
16: Judgment Day
To be clear, I'm not begrudging anyone an income here. I'm glad that if you want to record really good content and make money off it the mechanisms are now in place for you to do so (even if I don't love what that necessarily does to the content).
I'm not even annoyed that podcasts like Have A Word are so successful and clearly make a whole ton of cash - while the two hosts are comedians and the show started during the pandemic, ultimately they are running a small independent business and employing people, and I hope they would agree that pre-pandemic they were not on the level of a the A-list of British comedy who suddenly found themselves with the ability to have opinions on all sorts of topics for long enough to stick an ad for mattresses in the middle of them.
What I'm most annoyed about is the encroachment of the tech industry into a thing that they couldn't be bothered ruining for years because they finally smelled money - I may not be delighted by the sudden glut of celebrity podcasters, but at least these people make something, unlike the skittering little parasites who are so insistent on tearing apart a system that has been free and equitable for 2 decades.
I'm fed up of adverts for sister podcasts in the feeds of shows I'm listening to, that direct me to a url that I can't access because I live in the wrong country. I'm annoyed about RSS feeds with DRM. I'm annoyed about the deliberate fracturing of the podcast ecosystem behind separate apps. I might be an old man shouting at a cloud, but I wish The Industry would leave one thing I like alone before they choke it and drain the lifeblood totally.